Sir Jones the Indestructible posted his thoughts on Superman Returns, as did Jason Bannion, here, here and here. The two reviews aren't completely divergent, but they do represent fairly different takes on the movie.
And I agree with just about everything the two of them say. How about that! Isn't it wonderful, being a geek?
"Hey, Geek, how was the movie?"
"It was GREAT! Wow! It totally ROCKED! It KICKED ASS! And now, if you have a couple of hours, let me tell you what's WRONG with it!"
It's a curse, I tell you.